Detached House for sale at 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll - MLS: S12208769

new
for sale
for lease
sold
leased
terminated
expired
suspended

10 & 11 Methodist Island

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

$625,000

Virtual Tour

Neighbourhood

Port McNicoll
Major Intersection

Hwy 12 and William St.

Listed Since: 106 day(s)
Last update: today

Virtual Tour

Overview

Property Type

Detached, Bungalow-Raised
Bedrooms

3
Bathrooms

1
Basement

None
Kitchen

1
Total Parking

n/a
Lot Size

200.6x144.42 (Feet)
Taxes

$3,314.00 (2024)
Type

Freehold

Property Description

Property description for 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay

This charming family cottage offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and classic cottage living just a 5-minute boat ride from Victoria Harbour with easy access to Foodland, the LCBO, and other amenities. Located on sought-after Methodist Island, this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom retreat features a bright, open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings and a cozy loft overlooking the kitchen, dining area, and living room. A wood stove anchors the living space, creating the ideal atmosphere for relaxed evenings. Step outside onto the spacious front deck, perfect for dining al fresco or enjoying quiet mornings overlooking the yard. A fire pit invites late-night s'mores and stories under the stars, while a separate bunkie with its own screened porch and double bunk beds offers extra space for kids or guests. Boat-access only and surrounded by nature, this peaceful cottage is the quintessential Georgian Bay escape. Whether you're swimming off the dock, relaxing in the sun, or heading into town for supplies, this property delivers the best of both seclusion and convenience.

Listed by Sotheby's International Realty Canada

Property details

MLS #

S12208769
Sq. Ft

700-1100
Sq. Ft. Source

MLS
Lot Irregularities

n/a
Year Built

31-50
Pool

None
Drive

None
Garage

None
Total Parking

0
Family Room

N
Den

N
Exterior

Wood
Fireplace

Y
Roof

Metal
Foundation

Piers
Elevator

n/a
Water View

Y
Laundry Level

n/a
Heat

Other
A/C

None
Water

Other
Water Supply

n/a
Sewers

Septic
Central Vac

N

MLS #

S12208769
Sq. Ft

700-1100
Sq. Ft. Source

MLS
Lot Irregularities

n/a
Year Built

31-50
Pool

None
Drive

None
Garage

None
Total Parking

0
Family Room

N
Den

N
Exterior

Wood
Fireplace

Y
Roof

Metal
Foundation

Piers
Elevator

n/a
Water View

Y
Laundry Level

n/a
Heat

Other
A/C

None
Water

Other
Water Supply

n/a
Sewers

Septic
Central Vac

N

Living

5.82 x 3.81 ft Main level

Laminate, Wood Stove
Dining

3.81 x 3.33 ft Main level

Laminate, W/O To Deck
Kitchen

4.42 x 2.69 ft Main level

Laminate, Centre Island, W/O To Deck
Br

3.45 x 3.38 ft Main level

Laminate
2nd Br

2.74 x 2.41 ft Main level

Laminate
3rd Br

3.45 x 3.35 ft Main level

Laminate
Bathroom

2.54 x 2.18 ft Main level
Loft

3.63 x 3.63 ft Upper level

Laminate

Contact Manoj Kukreja

Sales Representative,
Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc.,
Brokerage
(647) 576 - 2100

Property History

Property history for 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay

This property has been sold 5 times before. Create your free account to explore sold prices, detailed property history, and more insider data.

Schools

Create your free account to explore schools near 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay.

Neighbourhood Amenities & Points of Interest

Find amenities near 10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay

There are no amenities available for this property at the moment.

Local Real Estate Price Trends for Detached in Port McNicoll

Active listings

Average Selling Price of a Detached

August 2025

$450,000

Last 3 Months

$481,444

Last 12 Months

$541,115

August 2024

$461,225

Last 3 Months LY

$530,090

Last 12 Months LY

$448,643

Change

-2%

Change

-9%

Change

21%

How many days Detached takes to sell (DOM)

August 2025

Last 3 Months

Last 12 Months

August 2024

Last 3 Months LY

Last 12 Months LY

Change

-28%

Change

-40%

Change

-26%

Average Selling price

Mortgage Calculator

This data is for informational purposes only.

Mortgage Payment per month
Principal Amount	Interest
Total Payable	Amortization

Property Price

Amortization

Rate of Interest

Down Payment ($)

Down Payment (%)

Closing Cost Calculator

This data is for informational purposes only.

Closing Cost Total for this property

Total Cash flow for purchasing this property

Purchase Price

First time home buyer

Down Payment($)

Down Payment(%)*

Additional information

Provincial Land Transfer Tax

Ontario Land Transfer Tax Rebate

Toronto Land Transfer Tax

Toronto Land Transfer Tax Rebate

PST on CMHC Insurance Premium

Lawyer Fees

$2,825

Government Registration Fee's

$164

Title Insurance

Closing Cost Total

Total Cash flow for purchasing this property

Provincial Land Transfer Tax

Ontario Land Transfer Tax Rebate

Toronto Land Transfer Tax

Toronto Land Transfer Tax Rebate

PST on CMHC Insurance Premium

Lawyer Fees

$2,825

Government Registarion Fee's

$164

Title Insurance

Purchase Price

Down Payment($)

Down Payment(%)*

First time home buyer

* A down payment of less than 20% is permitted only for first-time home buyers purchasing their principal residence. The minimum down payment required is 5% for the portion of the purchase price up to $500,000, and 10% for the portion between $500,000 and $1,500,000. For properties priced over $1,500,000, a minimum down payment of 20% is required.

Contact Manoj Kukreja

Sales Representative, Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc., Brokerage
(647) 576 - 2100

Similar Homes for Sale

141 Patterson Boulevard

Tay, Ontario, M1G 2J2 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
700-1100 Sq Ft
1 Baths
6 Garage

$599,000

218 Jephson Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 2A0 - Victoria Harbour

3+1 Bedrooms
1100-1500 Sq Ft
2 Baths
5 Garage

$679,900

426 David Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
1100-1500 Sq Ft
2 Baths
6 Garage

$599,777

Similar Properties Recently sold

628 Wayne Crescent

Midland, Ontario, L4R 5E2 - Midland

3+1 Bedrooms
700-1100 Sq Ft
2 Baths
3 Garage

$575,000

18 Fernanne Drive

Tiny, Ontario, L0L 2J0 - Rural Tiny

3+1 Bedrooms
700-1100 Sq Ft
1 Baths
6 Garage

$599,900

552 Is 80 Go Home Lake

Georgian Bay, Ontario, P0C 1H0 - Gibson

3 Bedrooms
700-1100 Sq Ft
1 Baths

$689,000